Guest Op-Ed: Fix It First, and Count the Carbon

Congress has given itself until December 11 to decide how the nation will spend more than half a trillion dollars on roads, bridges and transit over the next five years. The Senate has yet to produce a bill, and another short-term extension into 2027 is inevitable.

That delay is an opportunity for lawmakers to improve policy and accountability.

Since 2012, federal law has required states to measure the condition of pavement and bridges on the National Highway System and to set targets. That sounds rigorous. It is not. States choose their own targets, and with two narrow exceptions, nothing happens when they miss them. Poor-condition Interstate pavement may not exceed 5 percent, and poor bridge deck area on the system may not exceed 10 percent for three straight years. Everything else is a reporting exercise. A state can set a target that allows decline, meet it, and be counted a success.

The results show. The Federal Highway Administration’s latest count found about 21,000 miles of the National Highway System, roughly one mile in ten, with poor ride quality. Bridges are slipping too: the share of national highway bridge deck area in good condition fell every year from 2017 to 2022, from 43.4 percent to 40.4 percent. Today’s fair bridge is tomorrow’s poor one, and repair costs far less than replacement.

The House bill, the $580 billion BUILD America 250 Act, puts more money into bridges, including a formula that sends extra funds to states with more deck area in poor condition. More money is welcome. But a formula that rewards states for having poor bridges, without asking them to reduce that number, pays for the problem rather than solving it. The bill still does not require states to set or meet targets that improve over time.

Before lawmakers lock in five years of spending, they should restore priorities from the INVEST in America Act. That legislation passed the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and the Democratic-led House twice, under an open amendment process, but was never taken up by the Senate.

Those priorities include progressive repair standards. Every state would set targets that show measurable gains in good condition and measurable reductions in poor condition in each four-year performance period. States that fall short would direct a larger share of their formula funds to preservation and repair before building new lanes. Call it fix it first: protecting the investment taxpayers already made. Transit agencies must already set yearly state-of-good-repair targets. Highways should meet the same standards.

State-by-state measurement of carbon emissions from surface transportation, obliterated by this administration, must be restored, along with targets for reducing them. Congress can do that in a single sentence by adding carbon dioxide to the performance measures listed in the law.

Critics will say carbon accounting slows projects or punishes rural states with long distances to cover. Those concerns deserve answers, not dismissal. Let states choose their own strategies, and measure emissions per person or per mile so rural states are not penalized for their geography. But the claim that emissions cannot be measured is hard to credit from a program that already tracks truck travel-time reliability to the decimal point.

Billions of dollars for transit projects, particularly those aimed at reducing emissions (Low-No grants), have been withheld by this administration. This administration has talked about reallocating funds to areas with high marriage and birth rates. Congress needs to set ironclad criteria for disbursement of grants and build in penalties on DOT discretionary money if they are not followed.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has, remarkably, talked about “finishing the Interstate.” The system was proclaimed finished in 1992. Numerous dubious additions went unfinished even under 1970s criteria. Congress should make certain these zombie projects are not resuscitated.

Highway bill debates fixate on totals. The better question is what the money gets us. A bill that pours record sums into a system where roads and bridges may keep declining and emissions go uncounted would waste a rare chance.

With Democrats holding substantial majorities in the House and Senate, the 120th Congress has a unique opportunity to pass a 21st-century transportation bill, one that delivers roads and bridges that improve every year and a highway program that counts its carbon. These should not be partisan goals. Congress is the trustee of these public assets and they must act responsibly to preserve and enhance them.

Peter DeFazio represented Oregon in the U.S. House from 1987 to 2023 and chaired the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee from 2019 to 2023.

The views expressed above are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Eno Center for Transportation.

Search Eno Transportation Weekly

Latest Issues

Happening on the Hill